How the New Federal Scholarship Credit Will Reshape School Choice
A 50-state guide to what comes next
The July 2025 federal tax bill quietly created one of the most consequential education incentives in decades: a nationwide tax credit for donations to K–12 scholarship organizations. The credit is small ($1,700 per taxpayer), but the policy impact is large. It gives every state—red, blue, or purple—a new way to support private-school scholarships, tutoring, and educational services without spending state money.
Some states already have big scholarship ecosystems. Some have vouchers or education savings accounts (ESAs). Others have no school choice at all. This new federal credit changes the incentives for every one of them.
Below is a clear explanation of how the credit works, what it means for states, and a fresh classification of all 50 states based on how they’ll be affected.
Key Takeaways
A new federal tax credit (up to $1,700 per person) now subsidizes donations to Scholarship Granting Organizations (SGOs).
Scholarships can pay for private-school tuition, tutoring, transportation, therapy, home-education materials, and more.
States must “opt in,” but once they do, scholarships begin flowing with no state fiscal cost.
States with existing SGO tax credits can actually increase budget revenue by eliminating individual credits.
States with vouchers/ESAs can layer SGOs on top of existing programs at zero cost.
States with no school choice face a political—not financial—decision: whether to accept a federally subsidized scholarship system.
The policy subtly reduces the financial need for vouchers, while intensifying political debates about public-school enrollment and accountability.
How the Federal Credit Works
The new credit—embedded in the 2025 tax bill—lets individuals reduce their federal taxes by up to:
$1,700 each
$3,400 for a married couple (if each spouse donates)
To qualify, they must donate to a state-approved Scholarship Granting Organization. These SGOs award K–12 scholarships that can be used for:
Private-school tuition
Transportation
Tutoring
Hybrid and micro-school programs
Therapy services
Home-education materials
Curriculum
Educational software
The federal government pays for the incentive. States don’t.
But there’s one important catch:
If a donor gets a state tax credit for the same donation, the federal credit shrinks.
This “no double-dipping” rule is what reshapes the financial map for states.
The SGO Switch: A New Way In
A state must do just two things to activate the system:
Opt in
Approve SGOs
Once those steps happen, scholarships flow.
And here’s the surprising part:
Even states with no vouchers, no ESAs, and no tax-credit scholarships can suddenly have private-school scholarships—with no cost to the state.
That’s why this little federal credit has such big implications.
The Four Types of States (A 50-State Classification)
To understand how the new credit interacts with existing laws, states divide naturally into four groups.
Group 1: States with BOTH state tax-credit scholarships and vouchers/ESAs
AL, AZ, AR, FL, GA, IN, IA, LA, MT, NH, OH, OK, SC, UT
These states combine the strongest private-school choice systems with SGO-based tax credits. Now that the federal credit exists:
Their individual tax credits are redundant
Eliminating those credits can restore state revenue
Corporate credits still matter (corporations can’t use the federal credit)
These states can stabilize or even grow their scholarship systems while recovering state tax dollars.
Group 2: States with vouchers/ESAs but NO state tax-credit scholarships
MD, MS, NC, TN, TX, WV, WI, WY
These states already subsidize private schooling directly but have no SGO programs (yet).
The federal credit gives them:
A free expansion of private scholarship funding
No new paperwork for taxpayers
No cost to the state treasury
The smart move is simply:
→ Opt in and approve SGOs.
Group 3: States with SGO tax credits but NO vouchers/ESAs
KS, MO, NV, PA, RI, SD, VA
These states use SGO tax credits as their main school-choice vehicle.
Now, with the federal credit:
They can phase out individual state credits (increasing revenue)
Keep or refine corporate credits
Allow SGOs to expand without requiring the state to pass vouchers or ESAs
Group 4: No SGO credits, no vouchers, no ESAs
AK, CA, CO, CT, DE, HI, ID, IL, KY, ME, MA, MI, MN, ND, NE, NJ, NM, NY, OR, VT, WA
These states have stayed out of school choice almost entirely.
The federal credit gives them an unexpected option:
They can create a private scholarship ecosystem at zero state cost—simply by opting in.
Some will consider it. Others will reject it strongly. Either way, the fiscal barrier is gone. The fight becomes political.
How the Credit Changes State Incentives
States with SGO credits
Individual state credits no longer add value because the federal credit offsets them. Ending them increases revenue.
Corporate credits still matter because corporations can’t use the federal credit.
States with vouchers/ESAs
SGOs can complement existing systems at zero cost.
States with no school choice
They can access the benefits while avoiding direct state spending.
Or decline on philosophical grounds.
Does This Reduce the Need for Vouchers?
Somewhat.
SGOs provide:
private money
federal incentives
flexible uses
Vouchers/ESAs provide:
predictable public funding
universal eligibility
public accountability
SGOs weaken the fiscal case for vouchers but not the policy case.
The Political Dimension
Public-school advocates worry that:
Scholarships, even privately funded ones, may pull students from district schools
Enrollment declines may reduce school funding
SGOs lack strong oversight
States are enabling “choice by tax code,” not legislation
School-choice advocates argue:
The model uses private money
It offers flexibility beyond vouchers
It doesn’t reduce state education spending
It expands access for low- and middle-income families
Expect sharp debates in purple and blue states.
What Happens Next
This federal credit won’t transform American education overnight—but it shifts the incentives dramatically. States can enable private education scholarships:
without spending money,
without enacting vouchers,
without political risk to budgets.
They simply flip the SGO switch.
The next two years will determine which states take the offer and whether SGOs become a national parallel scholarship system.
Note from author:
Today’s post focuses on education policy.
Much of my work also covers real-world personal finance—how taxes, benefits, healthcare rules, and debt shape the decisions households actually face. Personal finance content can be obtained at the post below.
👉 https://bernsteinbook1958.substack.com/p/personal-finance-in-the-real-world
You may subscribe at either the free or paid level.
A coupon for the paid subscription is available here:
👉 https://bernsteinbook1958.substack.com/subscribe?coupon=4d9daaf9