Advice about Social Security often emphasizes the larger benefit received by people who delay claiming. But consider someone approaching 62 who plans to retire and wait until full retirement age—or age 70—to claim, only to see a sharp market decline reduce her savings at the beginning of retirement. Waiting now requires drawing down a depleted portfolio to pay current bills. Continuing to work might help, but health problems, layoffs, or caregiving responsibilities can make that impossible. Should someone in this circumstance claim Social Security earlier than planned to reduce withdrawals from a 401(k) that has fallen in value?
Claiming earlier provides income that reduces withdrawals from depleted retirement accounts. Selling fewer shares after a decline preserves more investments to participate in a possible recovery. The cost is a permanently smaller Social Security benefit, which could require greater portfolio withdrawals later or lower spending, depending on subsequent investment performance and longevity.
This is a question about sequence of returns risk: poor investment returns are especially damaging when they coincide with withdrawals early in retirement. Delaying Social Security can increase those initial withdrawals precisely when the portfolio is most vulnerable.
Consider a retiree who planned to withdraw $40,000 in the first year—4 percent of a $1 million 401(k)—while delaying Social Security. Before withdrawals begin, a 20 percent market decline reduces the account to $800,000. Maintaining the planned withdrawal now requires taking 5 percent of the remaining balance.
Suppose claiming Social Security at 62 would provide $2,000 a month. A full year of benefits would cover $24,000 of the planned $40,000, reducing the required 401(k) withdrawal to $16,000, or 2 percent of the depleted account. Ignoring taxes, investment returns, and payment timing, the account would end the year at $784,000 rather than $760,000. Claiming would reduce that year’s withdrawal by 60 percent, preserving $24,000 to participate in a possible market recovery.
This calculation illustrates the potential for immediate relief from claiming Social Security early during a market downturn. It does not establish a better lifetime outcome, which depends on longevity, subsequent investment returns, spending needs, taxes, and benefits available to a surviving spouse. Earlier claiming means a permanently smaller monthly benefit than waiting, and a market recovery is neither certain nor necessarily quick. Further research could compare the risk and timing of portfolio exhaustion under earlier claiming and continued delay across different market recovery paths, accounting for the larger benefit that waiting provides.
Derek Tharp examines this sequence-of-returns risk in “Why Delaying Social Security Benefits Isn’t Always the Best Decision.” His example of someone retiring before the financial crisis illustrates how early claiming can reduce portfolio pressure and spending cuts. It demonstrates a possible benefit rather than establishing a universal rule.
A more general framework appears in “Optimal Claiming of Social Security Benefits,” by Stephen Diamond, Stephen Boyd, David Greenberg, Mykel Kochenderfer, and Andrew Ang. Their model makes claiming depend on remaining wealth relative to the benefit available at full retirement age. Above a threshold, the individual delays; below it, claiming supports current consumption.
The implication is that a sensible claiming plan can change. A market decline could make earlier claiming preferable even when delaying was appropriate before the loss.
In his comment on Tharp’s article, Wade Pfau offers a specific response: someone delaying from 62 to 70 should build an eight-year TIPS ladder providing income equal to the age-70 benefit. He argues that the larger eventual Social Security benefit can reduce the withdrawal rate required from the remaining portfolio, even after funding the bridge. Existing savings can be reallocated to this purpose; additional saving is not necessarily required.
But how many households are prepared to implement this strategy? The Federal Reserve’s 2025 Survey of Consumer Finances reports that only 5.4% of families owned U.S. savings bonds, with median holdings of $1,000 among owners. These figures include EE and older series as well as I bonds. They do not measure TIPS ownership or identify retirees with a completed bridge, but they show that savings bonds are uncommon and that the typical owner’s holdings would finance little of an eight-year wait.
Access also matters. As I discuss in “An Inflation Hedge Locked out of Retirement Accounts,” Series I bonds are unavailable inside IRAs and 401(k)s. Individual TIPS can be purchased in a brokerage IRA, but workplace plans commonly emphasize funds. A conventional TIPS fund has no maturity date and does not provide the scheduled principal repayments of an individual-bond ladder. Someone with suitable brokerage access and investment knowledge—or professional help—has more options than someone relying on a limited plan menu.
I bonds accumulated outside retirement accounts could also help finance the wait, although their annual purchase limit and initial one-year holding requirement make advance preparation important. My general primer explains their uses and limitations. Allowing purchases within retirement accounts would expand the tools available for building an inflation-protected bridge.
Pfau’s strategy is compelling, but its usefulness depends on households having the assets, investment access, and expertise—or professional assistance—to implement it. We should not assume that most retirees are so equipped. A sound strategy for a well-prepared household does not resolve the predicament of someone who has already stopped working and suffered investment losses without securing that bridge. We should aim for a retirement system whose default saving and investment options help people finance the wait for larger benefits, making outcomes less dependent on individual foresight and investment expertise.


